Being offered a job is exciting. In a rush to schedule a start date, it is easy to overlook the key document, the contract, which governs your relationship with your employer. While it is easy and understandable to focus on salary, health insurance, and vacation days, it is important to take the time to carefully review all the terms in your work contract such as non-competes.
A non-compete is a contract provision that restricts where an employee can work during or after employment. For example, a non-compete might state that you cannot work for a competing company within 10 miles of your former employer's office for one year after your employment ends. Another example could be a restriction that prevents you from starting a similar business in the same city or working for a specific competitor for six months. These clauses can prevent an employee from starting their own business, working in a particular industry for a period, working for a business competitor, and so on.
New York state does not ban non-competes. However, restrictions limit how broad a non-compete can be. According to BDO Seidman v. Hirshberg, 93 N.Y.2d 382 (1999), non-competes can be upheld if they are reasonable, which is defined as: “is reasonable only if it: is no greater than is required for the protection of the legitimate interest of the employer, does not impose undue hardship on the employee, and is not injurious to the public.”
In plain English, this means a non-compete in New York must be limited to what the employer truly needs to protect its business, cannot be too harsh or unfair to the employee, and cannot harm the public. If a non-compete goes beyond these limits, a court is less likely to enforce it.
Two main ways non-competes are written are through geographic restrictions and timeline restrictions. A non-compete can restrict the geographic areas where a former employee can work. A non-compete can also enforce a period during which a worker cannot work for an identified competitor. However, non-competes can be negotiated. You may be able to discuss the scope or duration of the non-compete with your employer before signing, so you can advocate for terms that work better for you.
Employers use non-competes to protect legitimate business interests, including trade secrets and confidential information, customer relationships, and specialized training. Employers who sue their former employee in court can request damages and other forms of relief.
If you are considering a new job and are trying to understand your work contract or are seeking to find new work but want to ensure you aren’t violating your work contract, please feel free to reach out via zhamdan@hamdanlawfirmpllc.com